Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

First choice wasn't the best choice

"I fancied one girl and ended up with a different girl"

23
0 Comments 0
2.8k Views 2.8k
2.2k words 2.2k words

I was out with a fairly new mate Howard.  I had quickly discovered that he was more than a little hooked on alcohol.  Just a few days earlier I had seen his sister Lindsey for the first time.  Howard always called her Lindy.  I had thought that she was hot and a real stunner.  When I told Howard what I thought about his sister, he told me in a slurred  voice, she was a slut and I was welcomed to have a crack at her crack was how he put it.  He told me that a bottle or two of wine or cider was usually more than enough to lubricate her panties into sliding down her legs and off.  I thought that he was pretty derogatory the way he talked about his sister.   I couldn’t believe that she could be that easy. 

 

Howard and I were bout eighteen and Lindsey was two years older and was a college.  Howard even suggested that he could set me up with her the following weekend if I wanted.  I had already told Howard, but had to remind him, that I was off to family in Somerset the coming weekend.  Later after several more drinks I had to assist Howard to walk the short distance to his home.  Lindsey opened the door to us and was cross with Howard for being drunk yet again.  Although I could smell alcohol on her breath.

 

Between us we helped Howard to his room and virtually dropped him onto his bed and left him to sleep it off.  Lindsey asked if I wanted a coffee before making my way home.  I was more than happy to be sat talking to Lindsey, so I told her yes.  Over coffee Lindsey told me that whenever their parents were away, which was most of the time, Howard abused alcohol.  I told her I had noticed and that Howard said that she wasn’t much better.  Lindsey admitted that she did drink a bit too much, but nowhere near as bad as Howard did.  Coffee finished Lindsey kicked me out saying she needed her beauty sleep.  I tried to assure her that she didn’t need any as she was a real beauty anyway.

 

I walked home still fancying my luck with Lindsey.  At the weekend I was taken out and about by my cousins and we ended up at a cider barn.  It was real scrumpy and I soon found that it was very strong.  I remembered what Howard had sad about Linsey and cider and bought two one gallon flagons to take home with me.  During the week I asked Howard that if I had some good cider how could he set me up with Lindsey.  Howard told me to leave it up to him.  The following day Howard said it was all set up and one of Lindsey’s mates would be there, so he hoped that I had enough cider for four as he fancied his chances with almost any of Lindsey’s mates.

 

Saturday evening, I was shaking with excitement as I drove around to Howard and Lindsey’s house.  I had the two flagons with me.  I decided that one flagon should be more than enough and took just the one in with me.  I had warned Howard that it was very strong in alcohol.  I was a bit surprised to see that besides Lindsey she had three of her pals with her.  Howard broke out the half pint glasses as Lindsey introduced me to Naomi Amelia and Francis, the girls all seemed to call Fanny.

 

I was stunned just how quickly the four girls and Howard put half a pint of the cider away.  I was still sipping mine, knowing just how strong it was.  Then Howard was doing refills and they disappeared almost as quickly.  Howard poured himself a further half a pint.  The girls were all getting very giggly and it became quite ruckus when Lindsey suggested that we play a game.  When asked what game she was thinking of Lindsey very brazenly shouted out strip poker saying she couldn’t wait to see what I had in my jeans.  Amelia could see where this was leading to and excused herself to leave for home.   I was a little disappointed when Francis decided to leave with her.  I did wonder for just a moment how they were getting there as they were both staggering fairly badly.

 

On hearing Strip Poker, Howard was up and fetching a set of playing cards.  I expressed that I didn’t know how to play Poker let alone strip poker.  Lindsey laughed saying it didn’t matter as she intended to have my pants off in no time at all anyway.  Now just the four of us, for mime and Naomi’s benefits, Howard changed the game and told us the rules.  It still resulted in the losers taking clothes off.

 

It didn’t take too many hands before I was down to my shirt and Boxers.  Howard was in just his pants and both girls had bra and panties.  Howard won the next round which saw me losing my shirt and both girls took their bra’s off.  I could feel my cock already getting hard.  The luck was on my side when I won the next round.  I watched as Howard and the girls removed their final items of clothes.  As much as I fancied Lindsey, I could see that Naomi was just as sexy.

 

Now naked Howard took Naomi’s hand and led her away towards the bedrooms.  As they left I noticed that although Howard was better blessed down there he was still soft as his cock swung from side to side.  Not to be outdone Lindsey wrestled me on the floor to get my boxers off.  Not that I struggled very hard.  Now as naked the other three Lindsey told me to follow her and in a few moments we were in her bedroom and kissing and touching each other.

 

Lindsey was one sexy girl and as Howard had said some cider or wine always got her going.  I managed to manoeuvre us into the sixty nine position and found that Lindsey enjoyed oral sex.  It was only my third time going down on a girl, and I hoped that Lindsey didn’t think I was bad at it.  I needn’t have worried as Lindsey was soon groaning at my efforts as I licked her pussy and paying extra attention to her rather large clitoris.  Then Lindsey was telling me to fuck her.  This was like a dream come true as I turned around and slid between her legs and took aim.

 

Very quickly Lindsey was groaning loudly as she started to shake and throw her head from side to side.  Quite quickly her pussy was tightening like a vice on my cock making it hard to fuck in and out.  Not that I needed to much more as with just a few more thrusts both Lindsey and I were coming.  I had briefly wondered about contraception, but if she was as big a slut as Howard made out she was surely on the pill.  Then it was too late anyway as I was coming in her and she groaned and shook.

 

It was several minutes before I moved off of Lindsey.  I went to kiss her just to find she was asleep.  She was even beginning to snore a little.  I guessed that the cider had well and truly worked on her.  I lay for a little while stroking her sexy body.  I guessed that it was probably all over for me and went downstairs to find my clothes.

 

There in the lounge was Naomi, doing the same as me, getting dressed.  I asked had she enjoyed herself and was surprised to hear that she hadn’t.  Naomi said things were going well when they got to Howards bed.  They were kissing and touching and then Howard just fell asleep.  Naomi told me that she had laid next to Howard listening to me fucking Lindsey and wishing that it was her getting a good seeing to and not Lindsey.  I joked that perhaps I could help with that.

 

Minutes later we were upstairs again only this time in Howard and Lindsey’s parents bedroom.  Naomi had obviously handled the cider better than either Howard or Lindsey as we got into the sixty nine position and I had my fourth turn at sucking pussy.  Naomi seemed to enjoy it.  I know I did and she was better at sucking cock than what Lindsey was.

 

Then I put Naomi onto all fours and took her from behind.  Of the four girls I had been with this was my first go at doggy position and I knew that I had got it right as Naomi moaned and groaned and pushed back as we fucked.  Then I was having to hold her up as I pumped my second load of cum deep into Naomi’s pussy.  After recovering we both decided that we should leave the sleeping beauties to their beauty sleep.

 

I really fancied sleeping the whole night with Naomi, but my problem was that I still lived at home with my parents, so I had nowhere to take her.  To my surprise Naomi informed me that she lived with Amelia and Francis in a house not to far away.  She had a bedroom where we could continue to enjoy each other.

 

A ten minuet walk and we were undressing again and getting into Naomi’s single bed.  The cool night air had revived both of us and we were soon fucking each other a second time before settling down for the night.  I woke early and lay watching Naomi still sleeping.  I eventually got up and dressed and was about to leave when Amelia appeared and asked if I wanted a cup of tea.  Seeing her in her sexy pink nighty had me wanting anything but tea, but I said yes anyway.

 

As I watched Amelia move around the kitchen my cock was getting harder and harder.  I grabbed Amelia and pulled her to me and kissed her.  I was in luck she was kissing back and as I started to explore her sexy body she was doing the same to me.  I ended up fucking her doggy style bent over the kitchen table.  It was a rather quick and energetic fuck that saw us ending with a mutual climax.  We had barely straightened ourselves up when Francis appeared.   I think I said, “Oh, your up.”  To which Francis replied that it was hard not to be the noises I made with Naomi and now Amelia.  I could feel my face turning a bright red.

 

A few days later I was with Howard and he was bragging how well he had gotten on with Naomi.  I listened to him but I knew from what she had told me that he had failed to even get hard.  When I saw Linsey next she blew me off.  I didn’t mind as I was now seeing Naomi regularly and in between time I manage to sleep with both Amelia and Francis.

 

Since those young carefree days we have celebrated our own wedding and those of many of our friends, along with seventeen or eighteen birthdays and the births of our three children and their birthdays.  Naomi knew of my cheating with her house mates, and I am pretty sure that she also did her fair share of cheating at the time.  Now settled down with our children I look back at those days and see that I picked the right partner.

 

Lindsey got herself knocked up and now has five children all with different fathers and looks ten or more years older than she actually is.  I put that down to the drink that she still gets stuck into.  Francis has eaten herself towards a twenty five stone single woman.  Amelia is the only other one that has led a normal life.  She married a nice man and has two children just a little younger than ours.  As for Howard he drunk himself into a coma and died.

 

I was lucky that I picked the best of the four girls, and that whilst Lindsey was probably the best looking of the four and Naomi was in second place, Life doesn’t always leave you in that order.

Published 
Written by Lenny

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Match with Swingers near you
  • Arrange Meets with hot Swingers
  • Discover adult parties in your area
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Browse our real amateur Swingers gallery