if you work its your choice what you spend your money on.
i actually think benefit should not be cash at all.
you get a set amount for utilities, ensuring gas, electric, water is all provided and no child will be without. food vouchers are issued for food,not tobacco or alcohol.
if you dont like this get a job. in this country not paying your way grants you more rights than doing so.
i no doubt willbe flamed for this.
im not saying its easy to get a job, but you want respect and choices then earn that right.
benefits should be for no longer than a 6 month safety net and then if you stillhave no job you help out in the community ,even if only for 3 hours a week.
if you want the assistance of the state then i think its only fair that the tax payer knows the money for rent is spent on rent.
xx fem xx
I really hope none of you are ever in a situation so bad you need to claim benefits .... that you never feel depressed and worthless because you cant find a job or because smug 'tax payers' lord it above you that they can have a choice, they want to know where every penny is spent because they work but you don't. Because although they may have worked for 30 odd years (paying tax) in the same job and have now been laid off are of an age that you are virtually unemployable.
Think on those of us fortunate enough to be working at the moment - I know many working at LDV, again filing for administration, not knowing if they have a job or will have one. But they know if they are out of a job it will be very difficult to get another. There skill set isnt needed as much, look how long it took the Rover guys to find jobs and they was before the recession. Many of these people went to work there from school, probably have not got many qualifications relevant outside there current workplace.
Are you really saying a man of 50 after working 30 yrs and paying taxes isnt allowed during the time he is out of work to have a cheque sent to him to pay his landlord ? Is he that incapable - after all he has only worked for 30 yrs and ran a house and paid bills for that long too, but I suppose now he is out of work he cant even manage that hey ????
The original question was those on benefits.
When you work it is YOUR money that you have earned. If you fail to pay your rent, then you are in the same boat as to being evicted.
When on benefits there is a bit of a difference in that the person receiving those benefits are being given that money, solely for the purpose of paying that rent.
Most lenders now prefere you to set up a direct debit payment. The people like BT and Eon actually penalise you for not doing that. They like to know the money is set up to come out automatically, which ain't no good of course if the money is not there when called upon.
I really cannot understand why anyone would not want the most important thing...their rent, to be paid direct. Or would some look on that as a personnel slur?
It is not that, just a guarantee that it will be paid. The subtle difference here that I can see is that the council are giving you the money to pay the rent. If only a small percentage of those people spend that money,instead of paying their rent, then why not take away the temptation at source?
Kent at the risk of you thinking I'm picking on you can you explain the difference between earned income and benefits? I just cant see it.
Excellent post Pete I wish I had the abilty and balance to express myself so well.
I dont agree with tak avasion or evoidance on principle but I can understand your principles.
Kent, I still cant understand why people who receive their income from benefits should be treated any differently from people who dont. Thank you for your explanation of your reasoning though.
heres a thought..
if they think it gives the rights back to the claiment then why do the councils not also send them the ( on average) £900 per year that still gets paid direct to the council tax department? scared they might not recieve it?
xx fem xx
I agree this means of payment will be a I first read about this 18months ago I thought then this will become a farce.A lot of people out their particulaly those on benefit and the elderly will be the worst off as those who cannot deal with their own finances bwill be dropped right in it,and those who would have other priorities in life will just spend the money on booze,drugs,et al..
Also a lot more people are likely to be evicted because they will get into debt as they use the rent money for something else. So much for this caring Government,the Ministers or MP's will not have a problem they can afford to keep 2 homes. The sooner this crowd of sharks go the better.I was a Labour voter,but not any more I am voting for that Lib Dem lot as the only guy who has his finger on the economy is that Vince Cable.
Can somebody please please explain why being on benefits means you are unable tomanage your finances???????????????????????????
Where does this absoulutely moronic thinking process come from?
Kent the government say nothing about folkonbenefits finding managing their finances harder than those who arent. Neither does the web site link you posted. You and some other contributors to this thread have made that assertion and i would like to know why.
i work with people on benefit.
in cornwall its no longer going to be a choice if they want it paid to the landlord, it wont be a option.
now every person i have worked with in 7 years,and that over 800 have all said they do not want to recieve their HB direct.
in some situations the HB could be more than their benefit and they may well be tempted to dip into the HB payment.
christmas, birthdays, clothing, peer pressures, twatters of partners, risk of mucking up and bank charges eating into it, those are just some of the reasons the claiments have given.
if they get evicted due to non payment of rent the council will not do anything to help, even if they have children.
not all claiments feel its "their" money and think if the tax payers are paying then it should go direct to whats its ment for.
its a bollocks idea from the government nanny state who make up these rules for the people without consulting the people.
xx fem xx
*looks around....sighs loudly....walks away shaking head*