Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

The euro zone

last reply
232 replies
5.7k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Quote by Too Hot

much snipped..........
Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?
Before the cotton trade came about, wasn't it the French huguenots that built part of London you know today?
Did we not pilfer from many countries to earn our Status as you often put it of Great Britain?
Do you believe we did it all yourself?
Do you not think that many of us already have european blood line?
Do you think we did everything ourselves to get where we are?
Do you not believe united we stand, divided we fall?
Saying this I believe we should be part of europe, I believe we should have migrant workers which is controlled. we have done the same, people for years have traveled to live and work in other places.
I don't believe our laws and polices should be dictated.
I am not dead against a combined currency but I can never see how that would ever work.
If we can make our own polices, Law and keep our own currency, at present I see no other reasons not to join.
I have no claim to this land only the bit my house stands on. After all I am proud to say I and my children have all sorts of bits and pieces of blood line within us including French, Italian, Greek, Irish.
I am sure if you delve back you might just find the same applies.

Very sensible post and totally correct. Just to further the Polish wartime reference. The Battle of Britain could not have been won without the Polish fighter squadrons. This is completely irrelevant to the current debate but of course but worth remembering as we approach Holocaust Day.
I just added it as a thought of how we got here, where we are and how we can move forward with all considerations taken into effect. wink
Not just political gain and media hype.
I could add more that have contributed to this country in the past but shall leave it there for now. :wink:
Blimey if we go back far enough into our history, we may as well give these UK passports and work visas as well. loon We have all come from the same cloth so to speak if you really wanted to be silly.

That image is from Photobucket as well, I would presume that does not offend you in any way? rolleyes
As for the Poles in WW2 I think these people have helped the UK much sooner than 1939-1945, and a Ms Lumley had to use every trick in the book to get the British Government to change the rules on their ability to settle in the UK. So if you want to use the Polish as an example of a time of over 60 years ago, the Gurkas are much nearer than that.
Quote by Theladyisaminx
Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?

To save this country Minx? I really do not mean to be rude but have you any knowledge at all of the second world war at all? Have you any idea how the war started, and what country we had a pact with? How many of our soldiers died for that one single cause?
If you do not know then may I suggest a quick Google is your friend. Sorry but this country owes Poland nothing, but if you want to harp back about past times, then Poland owes this country the biggest debt of gratitude, and as for the French in that war I think the Germans took about a week to get France to capitulate. :notes: France had the same pact as us but in reality they were never strong enough.
Quote by starlightcouple
Blimey if we go back far enough into our history, we may as well give these UK passports and work visas as well. loon We have all come from the same cloth so to speak if you really wanted to be silly.

That image is from Photobucket as well, I would presume that does not offend you in any way? rolleyes
As for the Poles in WW2 I think these people have helped the UK much sooner than 1939-1945, and a Ms Lumley had to use every trick in the book to get the British Government to change the rules on their ability to settle in the UK. So if you want to use the Polish as an example of a time of over 60 years ago, the Gurkas are much nearer than that.

Forgive me if I am wrong but didn't Ms Lumley fight for the rights of the Gurkas and not the polish?
Quote by starlightcouple

Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?

To save this country Minx? I really do not mean to be rude but have you any knowledge at all of the second world war at all?

I know how the war started Star, do you know how the war was won?
Quote by Theladyisaminx
Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?

Your point is valid minx, but incorrect.
The Polish Air Force (Polskie Sily Powietrzne) did not fight in the Battle of Britain (10 July – 31 October 1940).
The RAF and RNAS fought for Britain during the Battle of Britain. The Polish Pilots you refer too had all escaped from the continent and were Commissioned or Atttested into the Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve. 145 Polish Pilots fought in the RAF during the battle of Britain, 30 of whom were killed and a further 36 died during the remainder of the war. The rest have since
Quote by Theladyisaminx
Forgive me if I am wrong but didn't Ms Lumley fight for the rights of the Gurkas and not the polish?

The point I made obviously went straight over your head. banghead
Quote by Theladyisaminx

Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?

To save this country Minx? I really do not mean to be rude but have you any knowledge at all of the second world war at all?

I know how the war started Star, do you know how the war was won?
Errrr yes I do Minx.

I can also find no reference of the Polish Air Force being involved in the Battle of Britain. Can you show me this please.
Quote by starlightcouple

Star I see you keep referring to the polish working here, I want to ask you did you know the polish air force fought the battle of Britian with us to save this country?

To save this country Minx? I really do not mean to be rude but have you any knowledge at all of the second world war at all?

I know how the war started Star, do you know how the war was won?
Errrr yes I do Minx.

I can also find no reference of the Polish Air Force being involved in the Battle of Britain. Can you show me this please.
I added this link once star on this thread which shows you don't read all posts.

Read through it Star you might get educated and then travel to North holt and then you can pay your respects to Polish Squadron 303, the best performing squadron in the Battle of Britain.
By the end of the war there were over poles in the RAF so they can help fight for our country but not work here. I think that is double standards if you ask me.
Some of the poles here could be descends from those that served this country and the forces I believe you honor.
Quote by starlightcouple
I can also find no reference of the Polish Air Force being involved in the Battle of Britain. Can you show me this please.

You are correct Star, the Polish Air force did not fight in the Battle of Britain.
Quote by flower411
I can also find no reference of the Polish Air Force being involved in the Battle of Britain. Can you show me this please.

Just out of interest Star ....do you know who the second world was fought against ?
Maybe link will help. They were Polish Squadrons, the Polish Government being in exile at the time.
Semantically you may be correct but the Polish Squadrons were effectively autonomous and treated like pieces of shit by the British Command despite their obvious ability.
What cannot and must not be forgotten is that these brave men fought and died for the freedom of the British.
Quote by GnV
What cannot and must not be forgotten is that these brave men fought and died for the freedom of the British.

Would not have it any other way GnV, but I for the life of me cannot work out why we should be grateful to Polish people of today or anyone else who helped us in a war over 60 years ago which I would say very few people if any on this site were alive when that war ended. History is something that we should not forget but Britain at the start came to their aid, and lost how many people in the process of that war that ensued from that pact?
This country along with France acted against Germany to honour a pact that this country had with Poland. I doubt if there are many Polish people who have come to the Uk in the last 20 years, give a toss about any of that to be honest. If any of them even know about the history, as a damn lot of British kids do not.
Without the British Poland would have been smashed beyond recognition. But whatever that situation brought about, I do not understand why we have to have some kind of thing where we should allow them all in.
That is the last word from me with regards to something that happened all those years ago. I salute anyone who died in the two great wars to protect this country from tyrants, something we are still doing today. We are supposed to be talking about the referendum .
The reality is that Poles along with the other European immigrants contribute more than they take which simply highlights the fact that looking to blame Jonny Foreigner is simply wrong. Little Englanders, unfortunately, have become a dumbed down species in recent years and have been bombarded with a blame culture all too visible on tv, radio, SMS and email adverts. It seems clear to me where the need to apportion blame has come from, particularly in people that seem unable to formulate an opinion based on actual research as opposed to becoming so easily hoodwinked by specific single interest propaganda.
As for the war .... Bit of a thread diversion.
I deal on a daily basis with people from all over the world and spend most of my days on talking to clients and prospective clients. In conversations with fellow Europeans, it is clear that there is a feeling, just like here, that the European Parliament has somehow passed a point whereby everyone feels like unelected dogsbodies are dictating National policies. Euro politicians need to listen to their electorate as much as DC is listening to the UK.
This really is a fantastic opportunity for Britain to lead the reform of the European institutions and the people of Europe - not just the UK - would support this. All countries in Europe need the best that Europe has to offer but the inefficiencies, unaccountability and pan European Directives are frustrating ALL of the people's of Europe.
Quote by flower411
The reality is that Poles along with the other European immigrants contribute more than they take which simply highlights the fact that looking to blame Jonny Foreigner is simply wrong. Little Englanders, unfortunately, have become a dumbed down species in recent years and have been bombarded with a blame culture all too visible on tv, radio, SMS and email adverts. It seems clear to me where the need to apportion blame has come from, particularly in people that seem unable to formulate an opinion based on actual research as opposed to becoming so easily hoodwinked by specific single interest propaganda.
As for the war .... Bit of a thread diversion.

I suppose it is possible that it may be in Camerons mind to supply facts about Europe and immigration from Europe and the rest of the world . But it remains to be seen whether or not the likes of the Daily Mail can be persuaded to print facts rather than just pander to prejudice.
As I said earlier in the thread some sort of test could be mandatory before people are allowed to vote. It would give people the chance to show that they have taken the time to actually consider the implications. Being unaware that, on balance, immigration is economically advantageous to the country should exclude people from having a say.
The Mary Beard posters from THAT now deceased web site are probably candidates to be denied a vote. In fact most people who ever posted on it are probably in the same boat.
Quote by TH
All countries in Europe need the best that Europe has to offer but the inefficiencies, unaccountability and pan European Directives are frustrating ALL of the people's of Europe.

:thumbup:
Quote by flower411
As I said earlier in the thread some sort of test could be mandatory before people are allowed to vote. It would give people the chance to show that they have taken the time to actually consider the implications. Being unaware that, on balance, immigration is economically advantageous to the country should exclude people from having a say.

Well it beats being labelled with the bigot or racist tag I suppose eh? rolleyes
Thank goodness it is not you that will make the decision as to who can or cannot vote. I am still waiting for your explanation as to what this ' test ' would actually be, and what part of society would have to take it.
In fact actually don't bother with the explanation of the ' test ' as thankfully your ideologies will never happen. It will be debated to death on the tv and people will rightly make their own minds up based on what is important to them. Whether that be the shape of bananas, or the ECHR, or the influx of immigrants. People will decide what is and what is not of importance, and vote accordingly. A bit like what happens in that other great constitution of ours....the General Elections !!
Democracy eh? Don't we just love it.:giggle: But a real bummer when idiots dare to get the vote.
Quote by star
Whether that be the shape of bananas....

Actually star, given that scientifically proven, the French hae the largest penis' in Europe, I'm for ever hopeful that being in France will give me some magical advantage :rascal:
Quote by GnV
Whether that be the shape of bananas....

Actually star, given that scientifically proven, the French are the largest penises' in Europe, I'm for ever hopeful that being in France will give me some magical advantage :rascal:
You sure this isn't the way this should read wink
bolt
Quote by flower411
The reality is that Poles along with the other European immigrants contribute more than they take which simply highlights the fact that looking to blame Jonny Foreigner is simply wrong. Little Englanders, unfortunately, have become a dumbed down species in recent years and have been bombarded with a blame culture all too visible on tv, radio, SMS and email adverts. It seems clear to me where the need to apportion blame has come from, particularly in people that seem unable to formulate an opinion based on actual research as opposed to becoming so easily hoodwinked by specific single interest propaganda.
As for the war .... Bit of a thread diversion.

I suppose it is possible that it may be in Camerons mind to supply facts about Europe and immigration from Europe and the rest of the world . But it remains to be seen whether or not the likes of the Daily Mail can be persuaded to print facts rather than just pander to prejudice.
As I said earlier in the thread some sort of test could be mandatory before people are allowed to vote. It would give people the chance to show that they have taken the time to actually consider the implications. Being unaware that, on balance, immigration is economically advantageous to the country should exclude people from having a say.
This is the point in my first post highlighting facts that I was trying to make flower which seemed to go over heads.
Most seem intent on making the vote in or out based upon the political power that runs this country who seem to all cock up the economical running of this country in one form or other and not always the people who generate the income and growth of our developed country and how we got here and from whom in the first place.
Although what do I know, I could be living in my own made up bubble being totally failing in the education system this country offered me or the media could teach me.
I'm with Star to a point.
1. The Polish Air Force never fought in the Battle of Britain.
2. How can democracy work, when you have to pass a test to take part in it?
David Cameron’s rather arrogant stance on European Union membership reminds me of a famous 1930 Daily Mirror headline: “Fog in Channel Continent Cut Off.”.........
Withdrawal from the European Union is a right of European Union (EU) member states under TEU Article 50: "Any Member State may decide to withdraw from the Union in accordance with its own constitutional requirements." No state has ever withdrawn, though some dependent territories or semi-autonomous areas have left. Of these, only Greenland has explicitly voted to leave, departing from the EU's predecessor, the European Economic Community (EEC), in 1985. No member state has ever held a national referendum on withdrawal from the European Union, though in 1975 the United Kingdom held a national referendum on withdrawal from its predecessor, the EEC; 67.2% of voters chose to remain in the Community. - source:

My own opinion:
Article 59: states that a member state must first inform the European council, which will produce guidelines under which the "Union" (the EU Commission) will negotiate a withdrawal agreement. This agreement is then subject to approval by the European parliament and the council of ministers.
The UK joined the European Union, then the European Economic Community (EEC) in January 1973. The decision, taken by Conservative prime minister Edward Heath, was extremely controversial and caused widespread division.
Labour's 1974 election manifesto promised a referendum on membership of the EEC. The party itself was deeply divided on the issue. A party conference held in April 1975 voted by a majority of around two to one to leave the EEC, with almost 3.7 million votes cast against membership (including the bloc votes of 39 of 46 affiliated unions). Those on the left of the party, notably Tony Benn and Michael Foot, were at the forefront of the anti-EEC campaign.
In the event, prime minister Harold Wilson, who proclaimed a pragmatic support for membership, committed the government to campaigning for a "yes" vote to the referendum question, "'Do you think the UK should stay in the European Community (Common Market)?" Acknowledging the extent of divisions, he allowed ministers to campaign against the government line, and seven members of his cabinet did so.
Nonetheless, on June 6th 1975, 67 per cent of those participating voted in favour of the EEC. The majority of those who had campaigned against the UK's membership admitted defeat.
The UK REBATE:
The UK rebate (often referred to as the British rebate) is a rebate on the United Kingdom's contribution to the EU budget paid back to the UK government by the European Union.
Calculated as approximately two-thirds of the amount by which UK payments into the EU exceed EU expenditure returning to the UK.
Currently the rebate is worth £5 billion.
I'll not comment on ukip for fear of being banned!
Paddy
Quote by Trevaunance
I'm with Star to a point.
1. The Polish Air Force never fought in the Battle of Britain.
2. How can democracy work, when you have to pass a test to take part in it?


Trev you couldnt be more wrong. Polish Air Force pilots flew with British Pilots at the Battle of Britain. There is even an exhibition for it by the RAF. but OK maybe the RAF got it wrong and didn't know who was flying with them.
Having a test before being allowed to vote does smack of elitism, hopefully when the time comes the Conservatives will be out so there will be no referendum.
Just cannot understand why so many harp on about the Poles who served with the RAF and forget the thousands of Polish Nazi's who served in the German army, including many who served as guards on concentration camps.
Quote by flower411
I`d say that democracy would work much better if people had to at least show that they had some knowledge of the things they were voting for.
As it stands the political parties aided by the media can lie about just about anything and pass it off as fact.
I don`t think it is elitist at all to require people to show that they know some facts before being allowed to vote.

in that case maybe the parties should be tested before they are allowed to stand for an election
id wager none would pass
Quote by dsfrancetoo
Just cannot understand why so many harp on about the Poles who served with the RAF and forget the thousands of Polish Nazi's who served in the German army, including many who served as guards on concentration camps.

I think that's an unfair argument to be honest.
The same could be said of the Alsacians (refers particularly to the Waffen SS) who were subsumed into German Command.
Quote by Stevie_and_Kitty
I'm with Star to a point.
1. The Polish Air Force never fought in the Battle of Britain.
2. How can democracy work, when you have to pass a test to take part in it?


Trev you couldnt be more wrong. Polish Air Force pilots flew with British Pilots at the Battle of Britain. There is even an exhibition for it by the RAF. but OK maybe the RAF got it wrong and didn't know who was flying with them.
On the contrary Stevie, I believe it is you that could not be more wrong.
The Polish Air Force (Polskie Sily Powietrzne) did not fight in the Battle of Britain (10 July – 31 October 1940). It simply did not exist at the time.
The RAF and RNAS fought for Britain during the Battle of Britain. The Polish Pilots you refer too had all escaped from the continent and were Commissioned or Atttested into the Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve. 145 Polish Pilots fought in the RAF during the battle of Britain, 30 of whom were killed and a further 36 died during the remainder of the war. The rest have since
An interesting thread is being hijacked by semantics. Of course the Polish Air Force no longer existed. The Polish Air Force proper ceased to exist as soon as the Nazis took power in Poland. Squadrons of Polish pilots flew with the RAF ( others had regrouped in France, a Polish squadron flying with the French Air Force up to the French defeat. ) and were referred to as the Polish Air Force ( or PAF ). Their use of PAF there would seem to be a colloquialism more than anything, they weren't the Polish Air Force proper, but the term was used.
Shall we move on? lol
Quote by neilinleeds
An interesting thread is being hijacked by semantics. Of course the Polish Air Force no longer existed. The Polish Air Force proper ceased to exist as soon as the Nazis took power in Poland. Squadrons of Polish pilots flew with the RAF ( others had regrouped in France, a Polish squadron flying with the French Air Force up to the French defeat. ) and were referred to as the Polish Air Force ( or PAF ). Their use of PAF there would seem to be a colloquialism more than anything, they weren't the Polish Air Force proper, but the term was used.
Shall we move on? lol

A good idea Neil and good points made. You are correct in that the Polish Air Forced ceased to exist as soon as the country fell to the Nazis. Thankfully though Neil after six years of fighting and Britain playing a major role in defeating the Nazis, the Polish people and then after a while the Polish Air Force were once again back in the hands of the Polish people.
Good on Britain and am sure the Polish people were and hopefully still are, thankful for all the sacrifices this country made for them from 1939-1945.
Now we can move on Neil. wink
Quote by flower411
Some of them may be teensy bit pissed off about the events after 1945 !

Nowhere near as pissed off if they were run and controlled by Hitler and the SS, had Germany have been the victors eh?
If some of them are now a bit pissed off because of any event after 1945, some might say maybe then we should have just ignored the pact, and let Germany have had their way with Poland.
Still I am sure Poland are more than aware of that fact, and in their history books always be grateful to this great and proud nation for saving their necks and their country, from the tyrant that was Adolf Hitler and his henchmen.