Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

Was this woman right?

last reply
80 replies
3.8k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Quote by kentswingers777
Can you not expand the logic?
I, and other forumites fought a 4/5 day long running battle on a thread in 'nillaville recently with a bunch of people- one in particular likened swinging to Paedophillia- who considered "us" to be lesser people, lesser parents, and lesser partners.
I think to say swinging is likened to paedophillia is a strange one indeed, and one I think is a comment of a mad person.
Mad people in your eyes, but they are living the so called normal life.
You need to ask yourself why you would not tell family and friends why you swing or let Mrs play with other men.
Or are the people you know mad too?
Or do you think they would judge you as you are judging others as you believe what you are doing isn't normal?
This is simply another side to the same coin.
Yes it is but on a slightly stranger scale
It is only a stranger scale because what you believe you are doing is ok
Consider this, your kids are still at school- and your nocturnal activities get found out by the local busybody. It gets out. It spreads around the school like wildfire. Your kids are ostracised. Suddenly, the sleepover is off. They're bullied. The party invitation is withdrawn...their lives are hell.
Whats to blame? Your sexual choices, surely? Or the small mindedness of the people and their reactions?
A bit of everything I think. I do not bother too much about peoples small mindedness or their reactions. Our sexual choices are ours to make, but obviously do not expect others to think it is ok. I do not think that being a swinger will result in sleepover being cancelled, or my kids being sent to Coventry...I may be wrong though but think most people would just wish they were swingers. lol
You do bother about small mindedness or you would tell people what you do, instead of hiding it.
I had a thread going once about telling our children that we swing. I said I would when they get to an age of understanding and can explain the reasons and why we thought it would be good for us. I seem to remeber you totally disagreeing with me at that time. As what impact that would have on them.
I know my children would not judge us as my mum and a couple of friends I have told haven't.
How do I know that I guess you would ask, because I have raised my children to accept people in life, not to judge others but ask themselves why someone would react the way they have, by finding out about people and not to think all peopla are like ourselves.
With gay people- they haven't even chosen to be gay. They just are. Are they lesser people for it? Less able to parent?
I never said they were less able to parent, nor are they lesser people because of it.
Mother nature intended than the product of M + F = B. Mother nature also made gays. I'd prefer, as it happens, that Fred & Bob took on a child from within the care system- but I'd also prefer Arthur & Sally to do that too.
That's a fair comment
You can't say in one breath that you're not homophobic- but deny two gay people the right to procreate with "help" that you'd give to straight people.
Yes I can. It does not make me or anybody else homophobic just because we do not agree with a child being brought up in a gay relationship. I simply asked will the child suffer because of it? I stand by what I said and I think they will. That may make me homophobioc is some peoples eyes, but I think that if you do not agree that is what people will label me, and so be it.
We can all have our own preferances what we ourselves like and how we conduct our own lives, but we can not expect everyone to be like us.
The child will grow up thinking their live is normal until someone points out it isn't. The person that points that out will be the person that expects everyone to be like them, they will be the person that has been bought up to think they are right as seeing it as wrong. I am thankful that it would not be one of my child that points that out, as they know not everyone is like them and dont expect them to be.
I have gay friends who'd make fab dads. I have straight friends who would make lousy parents. I have straight friends who'd make fab parents. If they fell into the "fab" category, I'd donate eggs etc to them regardless of gender. My decision would be based on their ability to parent.
I never said about parenting skills, purely that the child will suffer from bullying and horrid comments because of it. How do I know who would make good parents....look at baby P's Mother.
Would you advocate people not breeding because they were likely to have kids with ginger hair? Be too tall? Too short?
That is a silly comment as well you know and one which I will not bother to comment on.
I would have thought you would have said you would expect parents to parent and take responsibily for their own child. After all a parent is the person that is there for their children, through their lives, that loves them, cares for them, is intrested in making sure they conduct themselves well in society. As you know there does not have to be a blood tie to be a real Mum or Dad you just have to want to be a parent for the sake of the child, with the childs best intrests at heart.
All of these things are as likely to result in bullying as having gay parents. Extend the logic.
Yes they are and on that comment, you obviously class being brought up by gay parents as a possible means for that child to be bullied?
Phew......there were a few there Witchy. wink
Anything else let me know. cool

I just thought I would join this debate, sorry for sticking my nose in witcy and 777.
Witchy in Black
777 Blue
Me Minx in red :wink:
Tis a debate Minx- knock yerself out.
Besides, I like black wink
Quote by Witchy
Tis a debate Minx- knock yerself out.
Besides, I like black wink

You naughty girl.
Not a problem Minxy at all. It is nice to see you back posting as even though we seldom agree, you contribute to the forums in a positive way.
I always enjoy our banter whatever the discussion
Many of the contributions to this thread are deeply homophobic and prejudicial. The most worrying kind of bigots are those that dont even know they are.
Its an interesting debate regarding children wihin, what I guess at this point in time is called, Alernative relationships.
There is a transitional period in any society's climb on the evolutionary front when confronting new ideas and philosophies. This piece about children and same sex relationships is just one of them. Traditionally children are the product of a "straight" relationship so in times past anything other than that was not possible. OK i'm sure there are instances where surrogacy and the buying and selling of infants happened but that would of been very much a secretive thing.
All societies when evolving need pathfinders and martyrs to lead the way and its no different today. It still isn't widely accepted or i would dare say acceptable by the general populace today to see children brought up in same sex relationships. Of course things are changing and how we deal with the fact that and there are those to whom it matters enough to stick there necks out and challenge historically accepted views. Of course these people should be applauded if it is a just and worthwhile cause.
However with same sex parents of children there are going to be issues of being "different from the norm" there is no point in denying that. Just as having only one leg is not normal or being the only white person loving amongst a community of black people or vice versa. Wherever there is seen to be something unusual or atypical within the community there will be times that it is questioned and missunderstood found threatening or funny generally a focal point of interest.
In our local community i have no doubt that a single sex couple let alone a single sex couple with a child would suffer bullying. I find that unnacceptable personally and would hope that i had the nuts to stand up and say so if i witnessed such.
OK so is it right therefore that two adults of the same sex have a child that they know is going to suffer because of the actions of their parents? Whereas within swinging one can try and take and make great efforts in preserving the secrecy of it but having a child in same sex relationships is about as public a thing you can do and as such the parents must carry the weight of what the child is potentially going to suffer on their shoulders.
Is this right and does the child have a say? Is it fair that the beliefs of the parents in this matter of choice is forced onto the child? A hard choice to make if the child suffers through its parents beliefs if those beliefs are challenging accepted practice.
If I was gay would i make that choice to have chldren? I don't know, but I can see why people wouldn't for fear of being the reason for distress in a child. Lets face it it your making decisions that affect the children that they have no influence over.
Personally i hope and believe it will be acceptable and the norm one day and i guess i have an admiration for those who stick their necks and those of their children out to make it so.
Fifty years ago being a unmarried lone parent was something to be hushed and secretive about for fear of shame. We have, thank god moved on for the most part it is the same i'm sure for this debate.
Lets just congratulate ourselves for once that we live in Britain and its a society that lets us have this discussion and the freedon to explore possibilities rather than somewhere else in the world where these subjects would be unlawful and with dire consequence.
I wish some would just come right out and name names IF they think something has been said that breaks the AUP in anyway.
I see nothing homophoblc in this thread other than expressing a concern for a child, being brought up in a gay relationship, that many would think is not the " norm ".
How anyone sees that as homophoblc I do not know, or is being possibly labelled that enough to frighten people into keeping their opinions to themselves, for fear of being hounded? So if you say something that others do not like they can scream racist or whatever at you, and hopefully that person will sink into a corner, and keep their gob shut.
Freedom of speech is a wonderful thing but some want to stop it. Iraq is a lovely place this time of year. wink
Just a thought.
Quote by benrums0n
Many of the contributions to this thread are deeply homophobic and prejudicial. The most worrying kind of bigots are those that dont even know they are.

Ben I don't see it as such, some people here have said what they believe and are asking questions maybe to challege themselves and their beliefs. I think if people didnt stand up and question the otherside of the debate and hide their true feelings then I can see that being a problem.
I see when people question it might mean there is something they have no expierance in. so don't quiet get it.
Can't we stop pointing fingers and just debate?
Nothing ever is resolved when fingers are pointed and names are called, it doesn't matter in which direction.
They are all as bad as each other in my opinion.
Quote by Theladyisaminx
Many of the contributions to this thread are deeply homophobic and prejudicial. The most worrying kind of bigots are those that dont even know they are.

Ben I don't see it as such, some people here have said what they believe and are asking questions maybe to challege themselves and their beliefs. I think if people didnt stand up and question the otherside of the debate and hide their true feelings then I can see that being a problem.
I see when people question it might mean there is something they have no expierance in. so don't quiet get it.
Can't we stop pointing fingers and just debate?
Nothing ever is resolved when fingers are pointed and names are called, it doesn't matter in which direction.
They are all as bad as each other in my opinion
.
:thumbup: Spot on Minx
I'll join you if you dont mind max - well put Minx :thumbup:
Feel free Losty.......the more the merrier. biggrin
Justifying the discrimination against minorities by pointing out some of the prejudice and discrimination they face is quite the most ridiculous argument I have ever seen.
Quote by benrums0n
Justifying the discrimination against minorities by pointing out some of the prejudice and discrimination they face is quite the most ridiculous argument I have ever seen.

Benny......you talk all the time about " minorities " in society and how they get a rough deal. The law is there to protect that said " minority " and rightly so.
But.....and here is the but, will this child handed over to two gay men to bring up, not be in that same minority you talk about? If that is correct where is the law to protect that child? There is none at all, that will stop the possible bullying it will no doubt suffer.
It WILL be in a minority of children brought up in a gay relationship. That being the case and reading all your past arguements about minorities in society, I would have thought you would have wanted people to talk about it?
Will this child need protecting in the same way other minorities are? Or are you just going to go around in circles accusing people of being predjudiced or racist or whatever else you think people are, just because they do not fall in with your line of thinking?
I would like to hear your thoughts on this child being a minority and protecting it from possible predjudices and what can be done to protect it.
Is surrogacy bad? No, in my culture it is quite common for sisters to give babies away to their childless siblings.
Will a child be emotionally damaged by being the surrogate child of a gay partnership? No more or less than any other child. The challenges will be different but from what I have observed, the experience of prejudice often leads to a more rounded human being.
Are there any other objections to this perfectly rational and reasonable course of action?
As an aside why is this family in the national press? Surely that wasnt done with the intention of making it easier on the child or her parents was it?
Its about time we all stepped back and stopped picking on the oddballs. As swingers we are bloody abnormal in most peoples eyes.
Quote by kentswingers777
Justifying the discrimination against minorities by pointing out some of the prejudice and discrimination they face is quite the most ridiculous argument I have ever seen.

Benny......you talk all the time about " minorities " in society and how they get a rough deal. The law is there to protect that said " minority " and rightly so.
But.....and here is the but, will this child handed over to two gay men to bring up, not be in that same minority you talk about? If that is correct where is the law to protect that child? There is none at all, that will stop the possible bullying it will no doubt suffer.
It WILL be in a minority of children brought up in a gay relationship. That being the case and reading all your past arguements about minorities in society, I would have thought you would have wanted people to talk about it?
Will this child need protecting in the same way other minorities are? Or are you just going to go around in circles accusing people of being predjudiced or racist or whatever else you think people are, just because they do not fall in with your line of thinking?
I would like to hear your thoughts on this child being a minority and protecting it from possible predjudices and what can be done to protect it.
Why would this child need protecting being a minority, is he a minority cos of his parents sexuality? I dont think so. From past experience child at a very young age just accept things and unless they are told different by an adult I cant see there being a problem. But then again adults will always see something wrong with things that arent the "norm".
And thinking about it are my children a minority cos of my swinging life style?
It obviously has passed some people by. cool
Kent, please tell me that post is a joke. You’re not actually advocating what I think you’re advocating? That the way to prevent bullying is to prevent the existence of minority groups? Follow it through. You’d be banned from your lifestyle because it could cause your kids/grandkids to be picked on. Blondes and brunettes banned from breeding in case they produced ginger kids..people over a certain age being sterilised in case they have a kid with Down’s…
And this, from Mr “show no mercy, hang ‘em high!” himself! When did you ever advocate quashing the rights of the innocents in order to protect the bad guys?
Are you knitting a yoghurt scarf as you type?
Quote by Witchy
Kent, please tell me that post is a joke. You’re not actually advocating what I think you’re advocating? That the way to prevent bullying is to prevent the existence of minority groups? Follow it through. You’d be banned from your lifestyle because it could cause your kids/grandkids to be picked on. Blondes and brunettes banned from breeding in case they produced ginger kids..people over a certain age being sterilised in case they have a kid with Down’s…
And this, from Mr “show no mercy, hang ‘em high!” himself! When did you ever advocate quashing the rights of the innocents in order to protect the bad guys?
Are you knitting a yoghurt scarf as you type?

Witchy I really think you need to take one large chill pill sweetie.
NO I repeat NO that is NOT what I meant, as I think you well know.
I have made my feelings perfectly clear on this subject many times, but you seem to be not content with that. People accuse me of batting people into submission, well you have heard the last out of me on this thread.
My words have been twisted and words manipulated. I see no further point in continuing this subject in this thread.
If you are confused about anything I have written then go back over it, and to me it is perfectly clear..........gone.

Witchy I really think you need to take one large chill pill sweetie. (snip)
If you are confused about anything I have written then go back over it, and to me it is perfectly clear..........gone.
The last person to try this hard to get a rise out of me was the Pillsbury Dough Boy. rotflmao
You don't have what it takes wink