We prefer carpet - in my opinion, laminate is noisy, cold in winter and just not as homely (in my view).
Personally I would stay away from the deep shag pile though, cos not only is it harder to keep on top of in terms of cleaning, but also I think it looks untidy somehow... just too fluffy. I like the neat lines of a comfortable, warm-under-the-feet fitted carpet.
I also - weirdly - love the smell of new carpet!
Sawdust ......
would soak up the mess :wanker: