Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

The proposed banning of homework for primary school children

last reply
33 replies
1.2k views
0 watchers
0 likes
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno
Quote by jaymar
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

It test the parents' knowledge, you can not do that in a class room!
The purpose of it is to encourage independent study and to consolidate/practise what they've been learning in school. In theory.
However, I know that if I send homework, most of it will be done completely by parents or older siblings (even had it handed in, written in different handwriting!) or with a great deal of help, which renders it pointless. I've even had parents come in to complain that they couldn't do their offspring's homework rolleyes
As a parent, I could never see the point either - my daughter was just the same as yours, Mar. My son hardly ever did any homework and is still very lazy with it, but he just sails through everything.
As a teacher, I have to say that I do think it's pointless and putting too much pressure on certain kids, who stay up late or stress about it. Those who don't do homework, don't give a rat's arse if they get extra practise or not.
We can't actually insist on it being done anyway and to me, it just means one lot of marking less - I already know what my kids are capable of without them having to do homework.
Quote by jaymar
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

I believe a certain amount of homework is a good thing but only in years 5 and 6 (ages 10-11). As when my son started senior school the amount of homework was a shock to both him and I. This would prepare children a little for what is to come.
What I dont believe in is SATS based homework as this type of homework is purely to push school results. A friends daughter had 7hrs of homework a week in primary school (SATS based) Schools shouldn't put this pressure onto Children. I am lucky my children have about an hour a week and they get it done over the weekend.
Quote by
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

It test the parents' knowledge, you can not do that in a class room!
:shock: The Children should be able to do the homework themselves, as generally it is set on work that they have covered. I have never thought it is there to test the parents! biggrin
Primary school homework is ridiculous in my opinion.
My step children were privately educated and had home work from age 6. It was ridiculous. Their mom learnt more than they did and continues to do most of their home study for them in their teengae years. She was a bit annoyed when i asked her how well she had done in her exams this year.
My son and daughter (both teenagers at state schools)get far too much homework and although I appreciate the need to develop inedepndent study skills, I really dont see why that needs to be acomplished at home.
Quote by Theladyisaminx
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

It test the parents' knowledge, you can not do that in a class room!
:shock: The Children should be able to do the homework themselves, as generally it is set on work that they have covered. I have never thought it is there to test the parents! biggrin
He was joking, he has a very dry humour does our T wink
Thank you for your thoughts and a very honest one from FB. I couldn't agree more smile
My youngest dont have home work anyway, personally i'd just go along with what the school though was best, after all thats why we send our kids to school isnt it? if we are just going to disagree with what the teachers think is in the best interest of the kids whats the point sending them?
I think a certain amount of homework is no bad thing....
Its a nightmare trying to get our lad to do his but our daughter cant wait to get her books out when she gets home...
As long as its about 30 mins worth in the lower years then I dont see it does any harm..
Obviously as they progress the homework increases but then thats where they have to show some determination and grit and knuckle down if they want to aceive their goals I believe..
I have 2 sisters, who both have a child, and whose circumstances are very different.
Child "A"'s mum enjoys helping her with homework. She asks her to get her books out as soon as possible, explains anything the child can't understand, and encourages her to get on the family computer. The child's dad often helps pick out possible helpful websites, which leads to wonderful research and colour printed pictures.
This child enjoys doing very well at school.
My other sister is ill, has no partner and no computer. She does extremely well with her child, teaching her spellings, and trying to negotiate babysitters so that she herself can go to college to learn basic maths and English. She works part time, and is always shattered. Homework is usually done by the child on her own, on her knee in front of the TV.
This child hates homework, which causes distress to her and her mum.
Both girls are 7 years old.
My point is that homework at this age, can cause benefits for "advantaged" children, and disadvantaged children to be more disadvantaged.
I don't think the younger aged children should get homework...I can remember when my kids were in years 1 & 2 and they would be knackered when they got home from school, nevermind having to then do homework.
My 10 yr old son has problems with maths in school which we do help him with but the only problem with helping kids nowadays, with maths for example, is that the 'working out' method is vastly different from when we were in school. Most of the time, we ended up confusing him even more!!
It took me having to pay his teacher a visit and the teacher then showed me on the board examples of how multiplication and division is now done. Don't know about anyone else but I think its nuts the way they do it now!! lol
One thing I did stop doing was sitting with my son until he did every question right, even if he hadn't always took it in. By doing that, the teacher didn't realise that he was having problems with particular parts of the work so now, if my son can't understand a part of his homework, he leaves it blank and I write next to the question that he is having snags with it so the teacher is aware.
I think homework should only be introduced in Year 6 to prepare them for high school because of the huge amount they receive in secondary school.
I agree with it, the kids these days get far too much and it can cause grief at home for them. Nothing worse than nagging ya kids to do homework when they are as knackered as you after a hard days work.. they want to chill out just like us adults when we get home from work!
If they want some and see it as a fun after school passtime (some do love project work to do after school) great, let them do it as long as its healthy time..
I used to run an afterschool educational project where young peeps (11 - 18 yrs) got national certificates when they completed the different levels. These are equivelent to A/O Level etc or go towards units for other qualifications. We were packed out most nights and had a waiting list!!! They loved it, because it was their decision, fun and interesting. They chose what they wanted to do, had good support and had the run of the building/resources on offer.
It was interesting to see that a lot of those who attended wasn't sitting for most of the exams at school or were self excluded... yet they never failed to turn up for every session.
It took me having to pay his teacher a visit and the teacher then showed me on the board examples of how multiplication and division is now done. Don't know about anyone else but I think its nuts the way they do it now!! lol

I totally agree with you!
The way they work out Long multiplicatation now days goes on for pages. Baffled me :shock:
The type of family the child comes from is very very important in homework, in my opinion. Children from families where the parents take an active interest in their child's homework are bound to do better than those children who's books remain in their bags as the parents are just not there! (in body and mind confused )
This has an unfortunate knock on affect on the poor child's stress levels at returning to school having not had the same level of help and support at home.
It depends on what you count as homework as well. Children start bringing reading books home usually from reception age. It is essential that these skills are practised regularly and it is great for parents to help out in this way. Learning spellings is also common homework from a young age and is also a good way to consolidate patterns learned in school.
From a parents point of view, my year 2 child gets far too much homework - usually 20 to 30 minutes each night plus reading. This amount increases as the child moves up the school to about 40 minutes per night by the time the child reaches year 6.
From a teacher's point of view - you can't win with the type and amount of homework! Some parents insist on lots and complain if there isn't formal written work every night, while others think there is too much and children should be allowed to play. We do try to make it relevant to the curriculum and include lots of fun type activities where the children play games. Again - parents don't always agree with that!
Quote by jaymar
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

It test the parents' knowledge, you can not do that in a class room!
:shock: The Children should be able to do the homework themselves, as generally it is set on work that they have covered. I have never thought it is there to test the parents! biggrin
He was joking, he has a very dry humour does our T wink worship
When I did home work I was sometimes helped. Told how to do something, asked another question to move me along. I was never told the answer.
Travis
PS I was joking earlier.
Quote by Yorks_blonde
It depends on what you count as homework as well. Children start bringing reading books home usually from reception age. It is essential that these skills are practised regularly and it is great for parents to help out in this way. Learning spellings is also common homework from a young age and is also a good way to consolidate patterns learned in school.
From a parents point of view, my year 2 child gets far too much homework - usually 20 to 30 minutes each night plus reading. This amount increases as the child moves up the school to about 40 minutes per night by the time the child reaches year 6.
From a teacher's point of view - you can't win with the type and amount of homework! Some parents insist on lots and complain if there isn't formal written work every night, while others think there is too much and children should be allowed to play. We do try to make it relevant to the curriculum and include lots of fun type activities where the children play games. Again - parents don't always agree with that!

2 year old?? the poor mite, that's taking it way to far in my opinion.
I'm actually in agreement with reading books, reading is very very important. I think most parents tend to help their toddlers with reading in any event.
Quote by jaymar
It depends on what you count as homework as well. Children start bringing reading books home usually from reception age. It is essential that these skills are practised regularly and it is great for parents to help out in this way. Learning spellings is also common homework from a young age and is also a good way to consolidate patterns learned in school.
From a parents point of view, my year 2 child gets far too much homework - usually 20 to 30 minutes each night plus reading. This amount increases as the child moves up the school to about 40 minutes per night by the time the child reaches year 6.
From a teacher's point of view - you can't win with the type and amount of homework! Some parents insist on lots and complain if there isn't formal written work every night, while others think there is too much and children should be allowed to play. We do try to make it relevant to the curriculum and include lots of fun type activities where the children play games. Again - parents don't always agree with that!

2 year old?? the poor mite, that's taking it way to far in my opinion.
I'm actually in agreement with reading books, reading is very very important. I think most parents tend to help their toddlers with reading in any event.
I think Yorks means a child in year 2 dunno
(how old are they in year 2 confused )
Quote by Steve
It depends on what you count as homework as well. Children start bringing reading books home usually from reception age. It is essential that these skills are practised regularly and it is great for parents to help out in this way. Learning spellings is also common homework from a young age and is also a good way to consolidate patterns learned in school.
From a parents point of view, my year 2 child gets far too much homework - usually 20 to 30 minutes each night plus reading. This amount increases as the child moves up the school to about 40 minutes per night by the time the child reaches year 6.
From a teacher's point of view - you can't win with the type and amount of homework! Some parents insist on lots and complain if there isn't formal written work every night, while others think there is too much and children should be allowed to play. We do try to make it relevant to the curriculum and include lots of fun type activities where the children play games. Again - parents don't always agree with that!

2 year old?? the poor mite, that's taking it way to far in my opinion.
I'm actually in agreement with reading books, reading is very very important. I think most parents tend to help their toddlers with reading in any event.
I think Yorks means a child in year 2 dunno
(how old are they in year 2 confused )
oooooooooooooooh! wink
Year 2 I think is 5 maybe 6?
Quote by jaymar

I think Yorks means a child in year 2 dunno
(how old are they in year 2 confused )

oooooooooooooooh! wink
Year 2 I think is 5 maybe 6?
I wouldnt have a clue what year is what age anymore :lol2:
Quote by jaymar
On the news this morning, the PM has discussed the possibility of doing away with homework for primary school children.
I'd be in favour of that. My reasons? Children up to the age of 10 yrs old have trouble concentrating at the best of times. Personally I think sitting at 6pm/7pm at night doing more work can only put stress on the little mites. Surely 7 hours study 5 days a week is sufficient? I remember my daughter being miserable, tired, tetchy and simply not interested later on at night.
I'm all in favour of holiday homework, coursework as this keeps their brain cells ticking over.
I'm sure teacher members will come along and explain, but what is the purpose of homework in the first place at that young age? dunno

My 5 year old Grandaughter has homework of sorts. Things like her numbers and her spellings, she also does some reading at home with the Kipper books.
I cannot see any problem with that at all and she enjoys the time spent at home doing it. Yes sometimes she is tired but blimey 13 year olds get tired and don't want to do their homework. I think a small ammount done at home is perfectly ok for very small children and my Daughters teacher thinks it def helps the children at their early ages. drinkies
Year 2 is age 6 to 7. Year 6 is the top of primary and the children are 10 to 11.
smile
Quote by Yorks_blonde
Year 2 is age 6 to 7. Year 6 is the top of primary and the children are 10 to 11.
smile

Coorrr, thanks...glad you posted that :) :) ........Ive been trying to work it out for years! So the seniors are 7 to 11??? Or 12 if they stay in 6th form?
Yes Years 7 to 11 are high school and 12 and 13 are sixth form. A lot of schools still called it sixth form though(just to confuse people!).
smile
I changed schools at age 9 and had to do extensive homework, especially Algebra and Latin - I still have nightmares about it now!
Plim :cry: :cry:
Quote by Yorks_blonde
Yes Years 7 to 11 are high school and 12 and 13 are sixth form. A lot of schools still called it sixth form though(just to confuse people!).
smile

Ha! No wonder Im confused then :) ....... mind you, it doesnt take a lot confused :? Didnt realise it went up to 13, so thats what I would call upper sixth??
Go on then - how do you work out multiplication nowadays? I thought there was only 1 way (apart from a calculator).
Never would have thought I would be giving a maths lesson for parents on a swinging forum! smile
Children are taught lots of different methods for the four rules now. They are supposed to work by helping children understand them rather than the 'old fashioned' way of teaching I experienced at school which consisted of "do it this way because I say so and you don't need to understand it".
I have found a website that explains how each method works . A lot are based on children's place value understanding. That is that the 4 in 643 is worth 40 not just 4. You need to check with your child's school though because a lot of schools found that the number of different methods taught was confusing children (surprise surprise!) and chose just certain ones to use.
Whichever method your child's school uses, one of the best things a parent can do to help their child in maths is help them to learn their number bonds by heart. That is addition and subtraction facts up to 20+20 (so they can say for example that 6+8 is 14 without having to work it out) and their times tables up to 12x12. Times tables especially will help older primary children because they will then be able to work much more confidently with fractions, percentages, ratio and lots of other maths concepts.
By the way, from a personal point of view, I don't think there is anything wrong with the methods we were taught at school, but it does help some children to be able to use them when they understand how they work.
Right off to it now... 7 x 8 is???
lol :lol: