Join the most popular community of UK swingers now
Login

what has happened to humanity??

last reply
87 replies
3.9k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Taken from
Anglers managed to pull Bethany out but Jordon was out of sight before they could get to him.
The alarm was raised and the PCSOs arrived on the scene. Police said they could see no sign of Jordon in the water, so they radioed trained officers for help.

Of the 4 people who where at the bank NON went to look for the second child, if 4 people decided not to go in, 2 of which had already gone in once then I consider not going in was probably correct. The child could not be seen.
As for whether Police and Community Support Officers should place themselves in greater danger than any other person; they do each time they put on the uniform.
This incident is sad, but the report do not indicate that anyone could have done anything to change the out come after the children had entered the water.
Any one who is in the emergency services weather this be police fire ambulance or in fact anyon who has any first aid training is taught the same thing which is
DRAB
which stands for
DANGER
RESPONSE
AIRWAY
BREATHING

This is classed as primary or intial assement, Now if the PCSO who where first on scene made the assement it was to dangerous to jump in then they did nothing wrong as i always teach a dead hero is no goodand what is the point in give the ambulance service and us in the Hospital any more work then necessary police and ambulance are not train in swift water rescue
A Special Police Constable (volunteers) is different from Police Community Support Officers (Paid).
PCSO's are not employed to do police work, they are employed to take away the daily grind stuff to allow th police to do their jobs, catching villians etc. SPCO's do things like, house to house enquiries, helping at public events, crowd control and local community isses like graffiti, abondonded vehicles etc etc
They aren't allowed to deal with incidents, no matter how urgent they are. They dont have the training and its not part of their job role.
The PCSO's role orginially came from the old Street Warden Scheme. It was successful but governement funding stopped and the police felt it would be a huge loss as it was benificial to the local community and of course helped out the Police force considerably.
As others have said, I think the SPCO's acted in the best way without endangering others lives or there own.
Still a very sad case.....
for me it doesn`t matter what they are paid to do.
being a jobsworth doesn`t forgive the fact that they didn`t try. hope they can live with themselves and that they or their loved ones never need someone willing to have a go. just cowardice in my book
Quote by annejohn
for me it doesn`t matter what they are paid to do.
being a jobsworth doesn`t forgive the fact that they didn`t try. hope they can live with themselves and that they or their loved ones never need someone willing to have a go. just cowardice in my book

According to one news report, the step dad didn't try either and it was one of his loved ones; the regular police officer went into the water.
This water.
Quote by Freckledbird
for me it doesn`t matter what they are paid to do.
being a jobsworth doesn`t forgive the fact that they didn`t try. hope they can live with themselves and that they or their loved ones never need someone willing to have a go. just cowardice in my book

According to one news report, the step dad didn't try either and it was one of his loved ones; the regular police officer went into the water.
This water.

as Freckledbird says...the stepfather didn't do anything either...not even so much as getting his shoes wet!...did he come to the same conclusion as the officers that if they couldn't see anything they wouldn't know where to start!...as for the officer that did go into the water...he may have taken several attempts until he located the boy...unless you were actually there you have no ideas what you would do...your remarks are no different than what you would expect from The Sun for example!
Quote by annejohn
two community police officers are first on the scene where an 11 yr old boy is drowning after going into a pond to rescue his little they go in to help?
no, cos they aren`t trained (says their police spokesman ) passers by later went in by which time the boy was dead. trained? to pull a boy out of a pond ? i just feel so sad and sorry for the parents as well as for the rest of us if this is the world we want.

What do you expect from people who are cheep security guards which have been thought up by not too bright very well having visible presence but then what when something happens eh I can't do that, NOT them all and bring in real police with the money.
I think it is time to define some titles;
Police Officer: a person appointed local, with authority under the Queen to protect life and property, prevent breaches of the peace and detect crime.
Special Constable: an unpaid police officer with the same powers as a Regular Police Officer. (but there is a limit on the geographic areas that the powers exist in)
Community Police Officer: a police office dedicated to an area, is not part of a specialist team and is not meant to respond to emergency. This definition differs form force to force.
Community Support Officer: He/she has less powers and therefore less training than a police officer. They are also paid less.
Apologies for any paraphrasing.
WPC Angela Bradley
Died 5 January 1983, aged 23
PC Gordon Alexander Connolly
Died 5 January 1983, aged 24
PC Colin Morrison
Died 5 January 1983, aged 38
Drowned attempting to rescue a man and each other from the sea


Open water is dangerous and no rescue should be attempted by those untrained in specialist skills. These three police officers above all drowned because the man concerned went into the water to rescue his dog. FOUR people dead and one bedraggled but alive dog!
burning houses are much more dangerous,but you often hear of brave neighbours going in to rescue poeple trapped. its not down to what your paid or knew where the boy was last seen. i would have had a go.
no question
Quote by annejohn
burning houses are much more dangerous,but you often hear of brave neighbours going in to rescue poeple trapped. its not down to what your paid or knew where the boy was last seen. i would have had a go.
no question

And that's your choice. Other people wouldn't; don't condemn them for it. Or, if you're going to condemn the PCO's, condemn the stepdad as well.
Quote by annejohn
burning houses are much more dangerous,but you often hear of brave neighbours going in to rescue poeple trapped. its not down to what your paid or knew where the boy was last seen. i would have had a go.
no question

Each to their own and all that but you have no idea what you would do in any particular situation unless you were there!.
Personally I think the mother is trying to blame the officers as she herself feels guilty and helpless, the step father didn`t go in either and that alone must tell you something. The list of who to blame/condem could go on and on.
I feel desperatly sad for all involved, but trying to place blame where I personally don`t think it rests won`t bring the little lad back.
Quote by annejohn
burning houses are much more dangerous,but you often hear of brave neighbours going in to rescue poeple trapped. its not down to what your paid or knew where the boy was last seen. i would have had a go.
no question

Yes, and you often hear of brave neighbours dying in their attempts!
I'm happy that you feel you would have gone it - and I'm happy that the others chose not to go in. Each to their own and each to their own families. If you have no family to leave behind to mourn your rash actions then that's fine and dandy.
Strangely enough I was very touched to see one of the big blokes on DIY SOS ( redface ) last night talking about how he just realised what his selfish act of smoking could do to his young family (and he used the word 'selfish') - his actions impacted adversely on his children and could lead to his death.
:P
Quote by Jags
Strangely enough I was very touched to see one of the big blokes on DIY SOS ( redface ) last night talking about how he just realised what his selfish act of smoking could do to his young family (and he used the word 'selfish') - his actions impacted adversely on his children and could lead to his death.
:P

i watched that to it was very touching infact i thought the whole programme was rather sad :cry: :cry: :cry:
Quote by abybear1
two community police officers are first on the scene where an 11 yr old boy is drowning after going into a pond to rescue his little they go in to help?
no, cos they aren`t trained (says their police spokesman ) passers by later went in by which time the boy was dead. trained? to pull a boy out of a pond ? i just feel so sad and sorry for the parents as well as for the rest of us if this is the world we want.

What do you expect from people who are cheep security guards which have been thought up by not too bright very well having visible presence but then what when something happens eh I can't do that, NOT them all and bring in real police with the money.
this isn't even worth answering to! rolleyes
Quote by Jags
ncashire_Roll_of_
Open water is dangerous and no rescue should be attempted by those untrained in specialist skills.

:thumbup:
It's all very well being a 'have a go hero' when you're sitting comfortably at home watching the news, but I don't think anyone knows how they would actually react in a situation unless you actually find yourself in it.
I'm a trained Lifeguard, but even I couldn't say how I would have reacted in the circumstances, as I wasn't there. Obviously we would all like to do what ever we can to help others, but it does seem that in this instance, that the situation was dealt with in the safest possible way.
The one thing I do know is how dangerous ANY open water is, not just the sea, and that it should be treated with a great deal of respect and caution.
I was not there, therefore I will not say what happened there. However if I were a police officer receiving a call to a lake it may go like this;
Two fishermen dive in and save one of two children, the second one disappears under the water. The water is dark and murky. They then call the police.
Five minuets later I arrive. The child can not be seen, nor the bottom of the lake. I report by radio "Arrived at scene". I am not the first person at the scene but the Police Log will note I am first on scene. (I am the first officer or unit to arrive"
My first job is to access the situation and call for any support that may be needed. I ask the fishermen what happened. They know there is a child under water, they do not know where! It has now been six minutes. There is no way of finding the child expect by luck. Without oxygen we die, even for a short time, our brain starts to die.
I call for divers and/or boat the conduct a body search of the lake.
A second officer turns up and after twenty minutes recovers the dead body.
I do not know what happened that day, and the above is only a imagined reaction to an imagined incident.
What would you have done?
Quote by poshkate
I'm a trained Lifeguard, but even I couldn't say how I would have reacted in the circumstances, as I wasn't there. Obviously we would all like to do what ever we can to help others, but it does seem that in this instance, that the situation was dealt with in the safest possible way.
The one thing I do know is how dangerous ANY open water is, not just the sea, and that it should be treated with a great deal of respect and caution.

Even trained Lifeguards holding the RLSS NPLQ are not trained to effect a rescue in open water. The necessary qualification is the RLSS Bronze Medallion which is lifesaving - completely different to lifeguarding which is relevant only to swimming pools.
:P
Quote by Jags
Strangely enough I was very touched to see one of the big blokes on DIY SOS ( redface ) last night talking about how he just realised what his selfish act of smoking could do to his young family (and he used the word 'selfish') - his actions impacted adversely on his children and could lead to his death.

I saw that too, made me stop for a moment, and I don't even smoke
Quote by annejohn
for me it doesn`t matter what they are paid to do.
being a jobsworth doesn`t forgive the fact that they didn`t try. hope they can live with themselves and that they or their loved ones never need someone willing to have a go. just cowardice in my book

And I'm sure the PCSO's live with that thought every day
Just finished my First Aid re-sit, and one of the things that is taught, is with every casualty, assess the situation, and NEVER put yourself in any danger
As well as that, (if the course I was on is anything to go by) You are also told, that you contact the emergency services before attempting any other action, trained professionals are then on their way whilst the next step is taken
Was the PCSO's told by control to stand by and assist when trained professionals arrive?
We don't know the circumstances of that particular day, we don't know what instructions (if any) were issued
I have, and will continue, to be critical of the role of PCSO's, but I think you are going too far in classing them as Cowards
Cowards, confused, indifferent, indesisive, professional, we do not know the facts, only what the media has gathered from others who may or may not have know what was happening and then interpreted it. Then put it into a story that will sell their paper.
So lets leave the question to an inquest.
Quote by
Cowards, confused, indifferent, indesisive, professional, we do not know the facts, only what the media has gathered from others who may or may not have know what was happening and then interpreted it. Then put it into a story that will sell their paper.
So lets leave the question to an inquest.

The inquest has happened - accidental death.
Quote by Freckledbird
Cowards, confused, indifferent, indesisive, professional, we do not know the facts, only what the media has gathered from others who may or may not have know what was happening and then interpreted it. Then put it into a story that will sell their paper.
So lets leave the question to an inquest.

The inquest has happened - accidental death.
There would also be comments made about how others, notably the officers on scene behaved; 'such as there was nothing they could have done.' Those comments are not part of the verdict but are recorded in record. The record of the inquest is where to look for facts and comments on the conduct of those attending an incident, not the news papers.
Quote by
It has now been six minutes. There is no way of finding the child expect by luck. Without oxygen we die, even for a short time, our brain starts to die.

In that particular situation it might well have been too late but there have been people revived with no after effects having spent far longer under water. This is particularly true for immersion in cold water which reduces the bodies need for oxygen.
In a rescue situation if you are (safely) able to try to resuscitate a drowning victim do it, don’t just assume that it is too late. You can’t make things any worse!
In a situation like this emotions are running high but it is wrong to apportion blame. The child is dead and nothing will change that, those responsible are going to have a hard enough time. These “officers” are out on a limb and can only do what they are told. They have very little training, hardly any powers and little respect from the majority of police officers and some members of the public. Putting a uniform on someone doesn’t give them the knowledge, experience or training necessary to react properly in a life or death situation. We should have more fully trained police officers on the streets given the powers to deal with today’s problems.
Gordon Brown is making some positive noises about redressing the balance where crime concerned. I’d like to think that some of his ideas will be implemented but will believe it when I see it.
Eltigre
Quote by Eltigre
It has now been six minutes. There is no way of finding the child expect by luck. Without oxygen we die, even for a short time, our brain starts to die.

In that particular situation it might well have been too late but there have been people revived with no after effects having spent far longer under water. This is particularly true for immersion in cold water which reduces the bodies need for oxygen.
...EltigreYes I will give you that.
Cold water rushing to the back of the throat can trigger a reaction whereby the breathing channel closes and suffocation accrues rather than drowning. If the water is cold enough it is possible for the body to 'hibernate', requiring less oxygen.
So if the body is recoverable, do not give up, do CPR
Quote by
So if the body is recoverable, do not give up, do CPR

IF you are properly trained? confused
Non of us were there and unless you have been in that situation you dont know how exactly your going to respond so for those of you who are critising these people I think you should take a step back, I think we would all like to think that in any situation we would do everything we can to help but "hinsight" is a wonderful thing
In my job I take emergency calls and have to assess the situation without actually seeing the person and only with the information I recieve from them, I then have to decide which course of action to take, I do everything in my power to make sure I make the right decision but it makes me think if I did make the wrong decision and someone died would I be pounced upon and judged by people who wernt there and who didnt have all the facts......I think not
Quote by tina1
Non of us were there and unless you have been in that situation you dont know how exactly your going to respond so for those of you who are critising these people I think you should take a step back, I think we would all like to think that in any situation we would do everything we can to help but "hinsight" is a wonderful thing

Indeed :thumbup:
The two community police officers were there and they did know what they chose to do.
Again this is something that training had prepared them for.
freckledbird said
IF you are properly trained? icon_
poeple who aren`t properly trained can save lives with resuscitation, poeple were doing it before anyone was trained,thats how it becomes an thing about emergencies is that there usually isn`t a trained proffesional there,which is why ordinary folk have to do the right thing