Good for her, I hope she gets some help.
All my life when I can I have owned a dog, now for the first time we have two dogs, rescued from the RSPCA in Derby, we love them and they love us, their loyalty knows no bounds.
We sometimes go without to give them treats, the don't come cheap but they could, dogs are not expensive to keep they like her will eat budget food and scraps, they will still be better off with her than in kennels or roaming the streets because dogs love the company of humans.
She may have had her dogs a long time, I know Sasha would rather be living on the streets than give up her dogs, to some they are part of the family. especially to the old and disabled where their company can be an imense comfort.
We are not financially secure, we struggle to pay our bills but I would rather send her a £1 a week to help her keep her home and her dogs than see her have to lose them.
Is this what our Nation has come to, making people give up those they love to save a few pennies whilst squandering billions
what are you honestly trying to suggest here Flower...... you think she have put down or something. Pets and especially dogs, do become part of your extended family. Would you ever suggest poor families should put their kids up for adoption, as they could raise a few pounds and save themselves money in the long run !!!!
I am suggesting, that this lady has had these dogs before she knew the hardships they she was to endure. She is fully entitled to keep and look after them. As I said, your pets do become part of your extended family.
No I would not suggest she has any more. there again I'm sure she no intention of doing so. But you said you felt sorry for her hardship until you saw the dogs !!! I have one dog...I feed actually yestrday brought big bag of tesco dog food. Cost me and will feed the dog for at least a month, twice a day. a day !! not exactly going to break the bank now is it !!!
We don't live all over the world, we live in the UK, a UK that pays for 40,000 children to live a better life in Poland because one or more of their parents live in the UK, A UK that pays billions in overseas aid, a UK that raises billions for charities in poor countries, that gives Pakistan £750 million to aid their schools programme, that does so much for those not in our Country and you think we shouldn't let people have pets because we have hit hard times ?
Is there any point in us living ? are things here really that bad ?
What's next ? what else can we kill off that we cannot afford, it is this nation that cannot afford to pay for her dogs, because if we did not have to force her to move house she could keep her dogs.
And for what, she will be able to claim some of the moving costs, the council will spend a fortune getting her house ready for some other family to occupy, they just prepared a bungalow by us for new tennants to take over following the death of the previous tennant, the estimated bill simply to prepare it for the next tennant is in excess of £8000 then there are the other related costs the council may have to bear, reimbursing part or all of her moving costs, grants for decorating etc, without that it will take the council at least 10 years to recover the cost for moving her with the extra £14 they save on her housing benefit.
I can see the middle ground in this argument.
The woman has every right to keep her pets. It's her lifestyle choice.
She also has every right to remain where she is and forego the £14 per week. It's her lifestyle choice.
But to go on TV bemoaning the changes to the welfare system and plead for sympathy whilst appearing unwilling to change her lifestyle seems a bit hypocritical.
color=indigo]This is the first time in my life I am ashamed to be British and to have fought for you and this country, I never thought I would say that, that this is what we have become is a shame I find hard to endure. The greed of the "I have's" is appalling,
Being asked to give up your pets???? what next? give up your children???
FFS, I hope she gets help.
It is a difficult problem however i only earn just abve minimum wage, i get no finacial help from anyone or anywhere. I live in a house that i can only just afford and i dont have a spare bedroom, i can't afford to support 1 dog let alone 2 dogs.
So to be honest it does seem unfair that my taxes are going to help support people who can afford more than i can !
If she wants the spare bedroom then she should pay for it same as i would have to. It's her choice about the dogs and as she already has them then i presume she has already made some choices on how to budget her money.
As always with stories such as this, there is always a wider picture. Not seeing the news for this story but what I know is that she is disabled. I do not know her plight but many people lead very lonely lives and if really disabled I can imagine she would possibly have a very lonely existence in how many people visit her.
Her pet to her is probably a God send and how uncaring and totally lacking in any compassion, are those who would want her dog taken away from her to pay the extra money for her spare room. How utterly fucking heartless and I hope that anyone who thinks her dog should go, I hope they also fall on such hard times.
The bedroom tax has been brought in by people who have mansions of their own, and yet want to take more money from the poor and vulnerable in our society. How has this country become so uncaring for the disabled and the poor and the jobless and the homeless?
One of the surprises so far in this thread is that Too Hot has not come along to blame this disabled woman for a multitude of things. She cannot work I would presume and is claiming some kind of disability allowance. Just the kind of person the likes of TH and some others on here hate with a passion. These people see EU migrants come here and milk the system, but when it is a British disabled person asking for a bit of help, well another story.
What it must be like to be so heartless and show no compassion, is to me a bloody disgrace, and these people should be utterly ashamed of themselves, but then something tells me I am not suprised, hidden agendas and all that.
The trouble is that some of us are also disabled and poor (i am disabled and earn just above minimum wage) but we get no help at all but then see our taxes go to help others who have a bigger property and have enough money to suport pets aswell .... !
There are people here saying stuff her who support keeping terrorists in this country and paying thousands for them while wanting to take a disabled pensioners dogs from her.
Your moral high ground is lower than your sense of caring and that is lower than a snails slime, (wonder what made me think of a snails slime)
But they are not all bad, some are just attention seekers who always go for the controversial answer because they need to feel important
Because to some people a pet is as important as a child, some will never understand that and I understand why they won't, I accept they won't just as you must other must accept just how important a pet can be.
Personally I would knowingly put my life on the line for my dogs, I would go without for them, just as I would for my children, my dogs are loyal and loving, they ask only love and loyalty in return (and maybe the odd dental stick chewy) they greet me like a long lost best friend just for getting up in the morning, they would protect me should I need them to, they would put their lives on the line for me, if I open the front door they would be out like a shot, but 10 minutes later they would come back, of their own free will.
To many they are a lifeline, they help us find lost people, they help us spot the drug dealers, they tell us who has cancer, they show us the way if we are blind, they tell us the phone is ringing if we are deaf, they provide companionship when we are lonely, they can care for us more than children sometimes, I would not recommend anyone to replace family with dogs but for those that don't have family they are a total replacement.
Some will mistreat them, some will abuse them, some are indifferent to them and yes I bought my dogs, from the RSPCA for £350, the fact that I can buy them doesn't make them any different in my eyes.
We as humans do so much harm to animals in this world, it is nice once in a while to see us do the right thing by them.
First I never thought for one moment that you were one of them, second I believe that what I said about attention seekers is true, I don't have to prove it, I can think anything I want and that is what I think.
As for the terrorists, when I said kick him out, many defended his right to stay under law, when I said change the law they said it was wrong to do that, when I said just ignore the law and kick him out they said I was wrong, I know it would be wrong, I dont care, I say kick him out anyway but some will always defend his right to stay here whilst saying to an old disabled woman who probably paid her taxes most of her life - kill your dogs.
Personally i don't think she should have to get rid of the dogs but i do think she should either pay for the spare room or move.
Her plight is no different to many others and i feel her plight is better than mine for example .... i am disabled and so is she .... i work fulltime, get no finacial help from anyone or anywhere and only earn minimum wage which isn't much at all ..... i cut my cloth to suit my earnings (i don't have a spare room as i can't afford a bigger property) so i don't see why others shouldn't too !
She has the choice on how to sort out her finances same as all of us.
This country is in trouble finacially and some how we have to get it sorted out and if this helps then so be it !
It is possible, that one day, when your as old (your as in "if the cap fits") as this woman, if you are unfortunate enough to become disabled, if your loved ones are not with you, if your circumstances change you may want to have a dog or two for companionship and stay in the home you love even if it does have a spare bedroom, you might be the one thinking, I paid my taxes all my life, all I want is to stay in my hom e with my dogs :thrilled: